Proton VPN vs NordVPN: compare the privacy tools and the renewal bill

Research-based comparison: built from official pricing pages, documentation and specifications listed under Sources. We have not tested these hands-on. Facts are separated from our editorial notes, and we use no affiliate links.
Proton VPN and NordVPN both encrypt traffic between a supported device and a VPN server, but their subscriptions are packaged differently. Proton offers an ongoing free plan with restricted location selection and a one-device limit. NordVPN focuses on paid plans, with longer introductory terms and additional security products bundled into higher tiers. The right comparison starts with how many devices you need, which routing features matter, and how much you will pay when the offer ends.
Neither service should be selected on an unverified claim to be the fastest or to unlock every streaming catalog. Speeds depend on location, network conditions, protocol, and server load; streaming availability can change. This comparison instead uses official pricing and privacy documentation to separate observable product terms from performance promises. It also distinguishes a no-activity-logs policy from a claim that the company processes no account, payment, or operational data at all.
Quick summary
- Proton Free covers one device with unlimited data and automatically selected servers in ten countries.
- Proton VPN Plus supports ten simultaneous devices and adds location choice, NetShield, and advanced routing features.
- The cited Proton Plus offer is $35.88 for twelve months, renewing at $83.88 per year.
- NordVPN Basic's displayed offer is $80.73 for the first 27 months, renewing at $139.08 annually.
- Both publish no-activity-logging commitments, but those commitments do not eliminate account or operational data processing.
Comparison table
| Feature | Proton VPN | NordVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent free plan | Yes | No |
| Free device allowance | One simultaneous device | Not applicable |
| Paid device allowance | Ten simultaneous devices | Ten simultaneous devices |
| Compared introductory offer | Plus: $2.99/month equivalent for 12 months | Basic: $2.99/month equivalent for 27 months |
| Introductory upfront payment | $35.88 for 12 months | $80.73 for 27 months |
| Published annual renewal | Plus: $83.88/year | Basic: $139.08/year |
| Multi-hop option | Secure Core on paid plans | Double VPN on supported platforms |
| Filtering | NetShield on paid plans | Plan- and app-specific protections; full suite costs more |
| Logging commitment | No browsing, destination, IP, or session-length logs per policy | No activity logs; temporary session-limit data processed |
| Manual client configuration | OpenVPN and WireGuard on supported setups | OpenVPN on supported setups |
The clearest dividing line is Proton's permanent free tier
Proton Free gives one device an unlimited-data VPN connection without requiring a paid subscription. The trade-off is reduced control: its pricing page lists automatically selected servers across ten countries and a medium-speed service category. That label is a product tier, not a measured speed result. It is useful for basic protection on public networks, but it is not the same offer as choosing any Plus location for a particular destination or activity.
NordVPN does not advertise a permanent free plan. Its 30-day money-back guarantee provides a refund route for eligible purchases, not continuing no-cost access. That distinction matters for someone who only needs occasional VPN use and does not want another renewal obligation. Paying for either provider raises the simultaneous-device allowance to ten. Before choosing a family subscription, count concurrent devices rather than installed apps, and consider whether a supported router configuration is appropriate for devices without their own VPN client.
Identical $2.99 headlines conceal different commitments
Proton's cited VPN Plus promotion is $2.99 per month when $35.88 is paid for the first twelve months. The same page states a renewal of $83.88 every twelve months. NordVPN Basic also displays $2.99 per month, but its offer requires $80.73 upfront for the first 27 months, including three extra months, and then renews at $139.08 annually. Those are different cash commitments and different renewal prices despite the matching introductory headline.
NordVPN Complete is displayed at $3.99 monthly equivalent, or $107.73 for the first 27 months, renewing at $219.48 annually. Buy that bundle only if its additional protections and storage are useful to you. Proton Unlimited similarly bundles other Proton products and should not be confused with VPN Plus. Offers can change by campaign and region; the figures here describe the fetched US-dollar pages, not a universal lifetime price. Taxes and checkout eligibility can affect the final payment.
Advanced routing is a tool, not an automatic speed upgrade
Proton's Secure Core routes traffic through hardened entry servers before it exits through another VPN location. Its documentation discusses Switzerland, Iceland, and Sweden as Secure Core locations and presents the design as protection against certain compromised-exit or network-observation threats. That extra hop changes the trust and routing model, but it also adds distance and processing. It should be selected for a privacy requirement, not assumed to make downloads faster.
NordVPN offers Double VPN and Onion Over VPN as specialty options, alongside its NordLynx protocol. These are not identical to Secure Core, and availability differs by app and platform. Neither provider's list of features establishes a performance winner for your connection. This comparison does not report speed tests or guarantee access to a particular streaming service. For a practical evaluation, check the relevant locations, the protocol supported on your devices, and whether advanced routing remains available in the exact app or manual configuration you intend to use.
No activity logs does not mean no data processing
Proton VPN's service policy says it does not log browsing activity, traffic destinations, IP addresses, or session lengths. NordVPN also commits not to log internet activity, but its policy explains a limited operational exception for enforcing concurrent-session limits: username and last-session status information is automatically deleted within fifteen minutes after a session ends. That is more informative than treating no logs as a claim that no service data ever exists.
Account administration, payments, support conversations, and optional security products have their own data-processing implications. Read the scope of the policy for the product you enable rather than applying the VPN's traffic-logging promise to every bundled feature. A VPN also shifts network trust rather than eliminating it: the local network sees less destination information, while the VPN operator participates in carrying the traffic. Websites can still recognize logged-in accounts, and browser identifiers are not erased merely by changing the apparent source IP address.
App coverage and bundle details should decide the final shortlist
Both providers cover mainstream desktop and mobile systems, and both offer routes for supported routers and other devices. However, an operating-system logo does not guarantee identical functionality. Kill-switch behavior, specialty routing, split tunneling, filtering, and manual configuration support can differ. Browser extensions also protect a different scope of traffic from a full-device VPN application. Check the actual app needed by each device rather than assuming every feature travels with the subscription.
Proton Plus is a logical shortlist entry for someone who has used Free and now needs location selection, NetShield, or Secure Core. NordVPN Basic is worth evaluating when ten-device coverage and its specialty routing satisfy the requirement without a larger bundle. Higher tiers need a separate value judgment: domain filtering, downloaded-file scanning, identity-related services, and cloud storage are different products with different platform coverage. Choose the least expensive plan that delivers the required controls, record the renewal date, and avoid paying for security features that your devices cannot use.
Pricing (verified facts)
Proton VPN · Freemium
Free: Proton Free allows one simultaneous device, unlimited data, and automatically selected servers across ten countries; paid location choice and Plus features are excluded.
Paid: VPN Plus, introductory 12-month offer: $2.99 per month (US) · VPN Plus, annual renewal: $83.88 per year (US)
Displayed USD offer: $35.88 billed upfront for the first 12 months, equivalent to $2.99/month; renews at $83.88 every 12 months. Introductory eligibility and applicable tax depend on checkout. Other billing terms and Proton Unlimited bundles are separate offers. Checked 2026-11-17. Official pricing
NordVPN · Paid
Free: No free plan; eligible purchases have a 30-day money-back guarantee, which is not permanent free access.
Paid: Basic, introductory 27-month offer: $2.99 per month (US) · Basic, annual renewal: $139.08 per year (US) · Complete, introductory 27-month offer: $3.99 per month (US)
US pricing page displays Basic at $80.73 upfront for the first 27 months, including three extra months, then $139.08/year; Complete at $107.73 for the first 27 months, then $219.48/year. Monthly equivalents are introductory averages, not month-to-month charges. Sales tax may apply; offer length and bundles vary by region and campaign. Checked 2026-11-17. Official pricing
Proton VPN: strengths and limits
By Proton AG · Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, browser extensions, supported TVs and routers · Official website
A VPN service with a permanent free tier and paid privacy, routing, and location-selection features.
Key features
- Free plan with unlimited data and one active device
- Paid plans support ten simultaneous devices
- Plus server and country selection
- NetShield filtering for ads, trackers, and malware domains
- Secure Core routing through privacy-focused entry locations
- Paid P2P and streaming support
- Open-source applications and published security audit material
Advantages
- An ongoing Free plan allows evaluation without entering a paid renewal cycle
- Secure Core provides an explicit multi-hop privacy routing option
- Plus includes ten simultaneous connections
- VPN-only Plus can be chosen without purchasing the full Proton product bundle
Limitations
- Free users cannot freely choose any paid server location
- Free allows only one simultaneous device
- NetShield and Secure Core require a paid plan
- Secure Core adds routing distance and should not be assumed to improve speed
- Privacy:
- Proton VPN's policy says it does not log browsing activity, traffic destinations, IP addresses, or session lengths; this service-specific commitment is separate from Proton account and billing processing.
- Export:
- Supported OpenVPN or WireGuard configuration files can be used with compatible third-party clients and routers; native-app extras do not necessarily follow the configuration.
- Integrations:
- Proton account ecosystem, supported routers, manual VPN clients, and browser extensions; feature availability varies by platform.
- Support:
- Help articles and account support; paid plans advertise priority support and live chat.
NordVPN: strengths and limits
By Nord Security · Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, browser extensions, supported TVs and routers · Official website
A paid VPN with ten-device coverage, specialty routing, and higher-tier security bundles.
Key features
- Up to ten simultaneous device connections
- NordLynx VPN protocol
- Double VPN specialty routing on supported platforms
- Onion Over VPN server option
- Kill-switch and leak-protection functionality
- Basic-plan VPN and domain-level scam protection
- Higher-tier Threat Protection and cloud-storage bundles
Advantages
- Basic covers ten devices without requiring a higher bundle
- Double VPN and Onion Over VPN provide specialty routing choices
- NordLynx is available for a modern VPN protocol workflow
- Higher tiers combine VPN service with additional security and storage products
Limitations
- No continuing free plan is offered
- The displayed Basic renewal is much higher than the introductory monthly equivalent
- Full malware-defense and storage bundles are not included merely by buying Basic
- Specialty servers and security features differ between apps and platforms
- Privacy:
- NordVPN's policy says internet activity is not logged, but it temporarily retains a username and last-session status to enforce simultaneous-session limits, deleting that operational information within 15 minutes after session termination.
- Export:
- Manual OpenVPN configuration files support compatible clients and routers; app-specific protections and account services require their own setup.
- Integrations:
- Nord Account, native apps, browser extensions, supported router configurations, and higher-tier security or cloud-storage services.
- Support:
- Help center, email support, and live chat.
Who should choose which
Choose Proton VPN if…
- You need unlimited-data free access for one device
- Secure Core addresses your routing threat model
- You prefer the cited lower Plus annual renewal over NordVPN Basic's listed renewal
Choose NordVPN if…
- You want a paid ten-device service with NordLynx and specialty routing
- The longer upfront offer fits your budget and expected usage
- You have identified specific higher-tier protections you will actually use
Verdict
Editorial assessment based on the facts above
Proton VPN has the clearer case for ongoing free use and for buyers specifically seeking Secure Core. NordVPN suits users who want its paid app ecosystem, specialty routing, or a carefully chosen security bundle. The matching $2.99 introductory headlines are not equivalent purchases: compare upfront terms, renewal bills, and platform-specific features before subscribing.
Frequently asked questions
Which VPN can I use free indefinitely?
Proton Free is an ongoing plan with unlimited data, one simultaneous device, and automatically selected servers in ten countries. NordVPN has no permanent free plan; its refund guarantee is a different arrangement.
Do both paid services support ten devices?
Yes. Proton VPN Plus and NordVPN advertise up to ten simultaneous device connections. That limit concerns concurrent connections rather than simply the number of apps installed.
Is the $2.99 price billed every month?
Not for the offers compared here. Proton charges $35.88 for the first twelve months, while NordVPN Basic charges $80.73 for the first 27 months. The $2.99 figure is a monthly equivalent of an upfront payment.
What happens to the price when these offers renew?
The fetched Proton Plus offer renews at $83.88 every twelve months. NordVPN Basic's displayed offer renews at $139.08 per year, subject to the terms and notices governing the subscription.
Will either VPN make me anonymous to websites?
No. A VPN changes the network path and apparent IP address, but websites can still identify a signed-in account or recognize browser identifiers. Neither provider's no-activity-logs policy prevents those forms of recognition.
Free tools that help with this
Sources
- Proton VPN plans, offer totals, and renewal terms — accessed 2026-11-17
- Proton VPN service privacy policy — accessed 2026-11-17
- Proton Secure Core explanation — accessed 2026-11-17
- NordVPN US pricing and renewal terms — accessed 2026-11-17
- NordVPN privacy policy and session processing — accessed 2026-11-17
Related comparisons

Bitwarden vs 1Password: free access, family sharing, and vault security
Compare Bitwarden and 1Password on verified personal and family pricing, free access, vault encryption, sharing, exports, and developer-friendly features.
Facts checked 2026-11-17
ChatGPT vs Google Gemini: a standalone workspace or Google companion?
Compare ChatGPT and Google Gemini on research, connected apps, paid plans, privacy controls and practical workflows before choosing an AI assistant.
Facts checked 2026-11-17
ChatGPT vs Claude: choosing a research and coding workspace
Compare ChatGPT with Claude using official plan details, coding tools, project features, usage restrictions and consumer data controls before you pay.
Facts checked 2026-11-17